Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is the 5th most common cancer worldwide. Its incidence is very high in Asia and Africa and the incidence in Europe and the US is increasing. HCC can grow to a significant size before becoming symptomatic. Consequently, most HCC are diagnosed late and are not amenable to curative treatments, namely surgical resection and liver transplantation. Surgical treatment for patients with early stage HCC provides good long term survival. In patients with good liver function and a single HCC lesion < 5cm in diameter, the 5-year survival rate following surgical resection is 70%. In patients with HCC meeting the Milan criteria, the 5-year survival rate following liver transplantation is about 74%. The median survival of patients with advanced HCC on supportive care is about 14 – 16 weeks. Thus, early detection of HCC leads to a much better prognosis. At present, the only viable option for early detection of HCC is to undergo regular surveillance with blood tests for the tumour marker, alpha feto-protein (AFP), and ultrasound scan of the liver. However, the number, type and interval of tests can vary among physicians, institutions and countries. So what is the best schedule for the at-risk population?
Researchers from the University of Michigan recently performed a meta-analysis on 13 published studies using ultrasound and AFP for early HCC detection in patients with liver cirrhosis (Aliment Pharmacol Ther 2009; 30: 37 – 47). The study showed that the pooled sensitivity and specificity for ultrasound in detecting HCC at any stage is 94%. For detection of early HCC, the pooled sensitivity is 63%. However, surveillance intervals affected ultrasound sensitivity in detecting early HCC. When the surveillance interval was < 6 months, the pooled sensitivity is 70.1%. The pooled sensitivity drops to 50.1% when the surveillance intervals are between 6 and 12 months. (There is no difference in the sensitivity of ultrasound between European and Asian studies and between studies conducted before and after 1992. This suggests technological advances did not play a major role.) When AFP is added to ultrasound surveillance, the pooled sensitivity for early HCC detection increases to 69%.
The current guidelines from the American Association for the Study of Liver Disease (AASLD) and the European Association for the Study of the Liver recommend surveillance of cirrhotic patients with ultrasound with or without AFP every 6 – 12 months. The study above demonstrated a significantly higher sensitivity for early HCC detection when ultrasound scanning is performed at or less than 6 monthly intervals. In Japan, some institutions have a policy of screening the at risk population every 3 months and analysis of their data showed earlier detection of HCC which are also smaller in size at diagnosis. Although the above study only dealt with patients with liver cirrhosis, regular surveillance is recommended for all patients who are carriers of the hepatitis B (HBV) and C (HCV) virus, with or without liver cirrhosis. While it is tempting for an HBV and HCV carrier to think that “It will never happen to me so I don’t need surveillance”, I would certainly not take that chance if I were a carrier.

no comments »