Recently I had a consultation with the daughter of a patient suffering from pancreatic cancer. The mother had consulted a medical oncologist prior to seeing me. During that consultation, the daughter was told that with surgery the patient would likely live 10 to 12 months. With chemotherapy alone, she would live the same length of time. So is there a need for surgery?
Pancreatic cancer is not a ‘nice’ cancer to have. It is usually discovered late. Why? When you develop symptoms which cause you to consult a doctor, it is usually at an advanced stage. In the United States, there are 37,000 cases of pancreatic cancer per year and it is the 4th leading cause of cancer death. The only way to cure pancreas cancer is to perform an operation called pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD). PD removes the duodenum and part of the pancreas and patients are normally hospitalized for about 12 – 14 days. Due to the advanced stage at the time of presentation, PD is only possible in about 10-15% of pancreatic cancer patients. Despite a potentially curative operation, 80 – 90% of these patients eventually die from recurrent disease.
At the recent American College of Surgeons 93rd Clinical Congress, researchers from the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) presented their findings on whether PD could at least palliate the symptoms of pancreatic cancer better than no surgery at all. From 1994 to 2004, there were a total of 29,523 patients with pancreatic cancer on the California Cancer Registry. Of these, 1802 patients had PD and the lymph nodes were found to contain microscopic cancer deposits in 56% of cases. The study found that in those patients who were not suitable for PD, hospital readmission for intestinal obstruction was 70 - 90%, for bile duct obstruction was 30 – 50% and for abdominal pain 80 – 90%. In the group of patients who had PD, the hospital readmission rate for intestinal obstruction was 6 – 16%, for bile duct obstruction was 7 -12 % and for abdominal pain was 5 – 16%. The median survival for the PD patients was 17 months and 22.5% of the PD patients were never readmitted to the hospital.
For most patients and relatives, it is reasonable to surmise that for any patient with a condition, quality of life is more important than quantity of life. In the case of pancreatic cancer, undergoing a PD can be daunting. However, if PD can ensure a much reduced incidence of hospital readmission and improved quality of life, then it should be seriously considered as a ‘better’ treatment. If the ‘better’ treatment can also give you the potential chance of cure then it is an added bonus.
Quality or quantity? Sometimes, you could have both!
