Colorectal cancer is the second most common cancer in the world. The most common site for cancer spread is to the lymph nodes around the colon cancer. Once the spread has gone beyond the lymph nodes, the most common site for the colon cancer cells to lodge and grow within the body is the liver.
Colon cancer deposits in the liver are called colorectal liver metastases (CLM). It is estimated that about 50% of patients with colorectal cancer will develop CLM at some point in time. These liver metastases are usually detected by performing an ultrasound scan (USS) or a CT scan of the liver. The treatment options available to these patients are liver resection for cure or palliation with chemotherapy. For those patients with inoperable CLM the treatment is chemotherapy. In a proportion of patients, the chemotherapy treatment can cause one or more of the liver lesions to shrink and even ‘disappear’ on subsequent CT scans. When the lesion disappears, some oncologists and patients consider this as a sign of cure, but is it?
When liver metastases disappear on CT scanning, it is termed a complete radiological response (cRR) to chemotherapy. However, what is not entirely clear is that when a liver metastasis is completely invisible on CT scan, does it mean that there will be no viable cancer cells present when the previously affected site is examined under the microscope? The complete disappearance of cancer cells in the previously affected site following chemotherapy is called complete pathological response (cPR). There is only one way for doctors to determine cPR and that is to remove the affected site and submit it to microscopic examination by a pathologist.
What is the significance of a cPR over a cRR? When a lesion shows cPR there are no viable cancer cells present and the cancer is unable to ‘re-appear’ in that site. In cRR there are possible viable cancer cells and given time these dormant cancer cells will grow. Eventually this collection of cancer cells will become visible CLM again on subsequent CT scans.
A recent publication from France titled “Complete response of colorectal liver metastases after chemotherapy: Does it mean cure?” (J Clin Oncol 2006; 24: 3939 – 3945) looked at this issue specifically. In the study, systemic chemotherapy managed to cause 66 of 183 CLM (36%) to disappear on CT and trans-abdominal USS scanning. Before surgery, 20 CLM in 9 patients had cRR demonstrated on scanning. However, at the time of surgery, USS of the liver showed that these 20 CLM had not completely disappeared and were indeed still present. In 15 patients who had cRR, the previously affected liver was examined with USS during surgery to confirm that the CLM was truly not visible. The liver surgeon went ahead and removed the previously affected region of the liver and subjected it to microscopic examination. In 80% of the cases, the previously affected area contained live cancer cells. In another group of patients who together had 31 CLM showing cRR, the surgeons at operation only performed USS of the liver to confirm that these CLM were truly not visible. These affected areas of the liver were left alone. After one year of observation, 74% of these ‘cured’ areas had cancer recurrence and became visible CLM on CT scanning.
This study has shown that cRR does NOT mean cPR. While present day chemotherapy drugs are very powerful and can make CLM disappear on CT and USS scanning, what is not shown on scanning the liver does not equate to no disease. USS of the liver at the time of surgery showed that 10.9% of the CLM thought to have cRR by pre-surgery scanning were actually still present and not cRR. The high percentage of recurrent CLM in the liver (74%) of patients with cRR and the detection of live cancer cells in 80% of removed liver tissue showing cRR can only mean one thing. The only sure way of getting rid of the cancer is to completely remove the previously affected area from your body.
As the age old saying goes - Looks can be deceiving!
